TEXT E
Literature and Life
In a reaction against a too-rigid, over-refined classical curriculum, some
educational philosophers have swung sharply to an espousal of "life experience"
as the sole source of learning. Using their narrow interpretation of John
Dewey’s theories as a base for support, they conclude that only through "doing"
can learning take place. Spouting such phrases as "Teach the child, not the
subject," they demand, without sensing its absurdity, an end to rigorous study
as a means of opening the way to learning. While not all adherents to this
approach would totally eliminate a study of great hooks, the influence of this
philosophy has been felt in the public school curricula, as evidenced by the
gradual subordination of great literature. What is the purpose
of literature Why read, if life alone is to be our teacher James Joyce states
that the artist reveals the human situation by re-creating life out of life;
Aristotle that art presents universal truths because its form is taken from
nature. Thus, consciously or otherwise, the great writer reveals the human
situation most tellingly, extending our understanding of ourselves anti our
world. We can soar with the writer to the heights of man’s
aspirations, or plummeting with him to tragic despair. The works of Steinbeck,
Anderson, and Salinger; the poetry of Whitman, Sandburg, and Frost; the plays of
Ibsen, Miller, and O’Neill; all present starkly realistic portrayals of life’s
problems. Reality Yes! But how much wider is the understanding we gain than
that attained by viewing life through the keyhole of our single
existence. Can we measure the richness gained by the young
reader venturing down the Mississippi with Tom and Huck, or cheering Ivanhoe as
be battles the Black Knight; the deepening understanding of the mature reader of
the tragic South of William Faulkner and Tennessee Williams, of the awesome
determination and frailty of Patrick White’s Australian pioneers
This function of literature, the enlarging of our own life sphere, is of
itself of major importance. Addition- ally, however, it has been suggested that
solutions of social problems maybe suggested in the study of literature. The
overweening ambitions of political leaders and their sneering contempt for the
law--did not appear for the first time in the writings of Bernstein and
Woodward; the problems, and the consequent actions, of the guilt ridden did not
await the appearance of the bearded psychoanalyst of the twentieth
century. Federal judge Learned Hand has written, "I venture to
believe that it is as important to a judge called upon to pass on a question of
constitutional law, to have at least a bowing acquaintance with Thucydides,
Gibbon, and Carlyle, with Homer, Dante, Shakespeare, and Milton, with Montaigne
and Rabelais, with Plato, Bacon, Hume, and Kant, as with the books which have
been specifically written on the subject. For in such matters everything tums
upon the spirit in which he approaches the questions before him. "But what of
our dissenters Can we overcome the disapproval of their "life experience
classroom" theory of learning We must start with the- field of agreement
that education should serve to improve the individual and society. We must
educate them to the understanding that the voice of human experience should
stretch our human faculties, and open us to learning. We must convince them--in
their own personal language perhaps--of the "togetherness" of life and art; we
must prove to them that far from being separate, literature is that part of life
which illuminates life. (578) The author’s purpose in this passage is to ______.
A.list those writers who make up the backbone of a great literature curriculum B.compare the young reader’s experience with literature to that of the mature readers C.plead for the retention of great literature as a fundamental part of the curriculum D.advocate the adoption of the "life experience" approach to teaching