We wouldn’t have imagined it After years on top,
Nike suddenly looks like a world-class marathoner who, in mid-race, questions
whether he’s got what it takes to keep on running. Nike’s symptoms of distress:
a global glut of shoes, flat sales in key market, and declining profits.
Moreover, the global brand champ that captured its own winning corporate mindset
with the "Just do it" ad slogan has a new pitch. "I can"— to which investors
seem to be restoring. "No, you can’t." Losing faith, they have knocked Nike
stock from its all time high of $76 about a year ago to a recent $46.
What happened While Nike has tripped on fickle fashion trends and
heightened competition before, its main obstacle today appears to be its own
success. Here’s why: Big-brand backlash. When he founded Nike
in 1972, CEO Phil Knight contended that "if five cool guys—the best and most
popular athletes—wore his shoes, other people would want to as well. The
strategy worked wonderfully, of course, and now Nike controls an astounding 47%
of the U.S. athletic shoe market. But the brand has become too common to be
cool. "I call it the Izod syndrome." says John Horan., publisher of Sporting
Goods Intelligence, referring to the once-hip golf shirt. "Nike is everywhere."
Brand expert Watts Wacker, chairman of the consulting firm First Matter,
believes that the ubiquity of the Nike logo —the over—Swooshing of America—turns
off important core consumers, the 12-24-year-olds. "When I was
growing up: we used to say to that rooting for Yankees is like rooting for U.S.
Steel," Wacker says. "Today, rooting for Nike is like rooting for
Microsoft." The Marlboro mistake. Indeed, many cool-conscious
youngsters have gravitated to other brands such as Adidas (which sells sneakers
at lower prices) and Timberland (a leader in the outdoorsy "brown shoes" trend).
Instead of responding with hotter products or lower prices, Nike did what many
overconfident giants do (think Marlboro, pre-Marlboro Friday): It raises its
price ahead of inflation. "Retailers loaded up, but the products weren’t
necessarily reaching consumers’ closets," says Josie Esquivel, who follows Nike
for Morgan Stanley Dean Witter. Now, Nike is paying with price cuts—in the 50%
range—last tear’s models (except the irrepressible Air Jordan line).
The (Asian) economy, stupid. Nike’s inventory glut is messiest in Asia,
largely because the company operates few outlet stores there. (In the U.S. Nike
sells almost half of its leftover shoes through its 41 factory stores and the
rest through discounters like T. J. Max) Also, Nike was particularly ill
prepared for Asia’s economic collapse because Knight has long believed his
company’s sales are recession-resistant. Management expected revenues in Asia to
almost double this year, from $1.2 billion, but retailers canceled orders at
alarming rates. It looks as though sales will rise marginally at best.
Waffling on Wall Street. Nike worsened its woes by failing to acknowledge
them soon enough. "Early last year, there was a major crack I the day," says
analyst Esquivel. "It took them over two months to say, ’Oops, we have
problems." She lowered her rating on the stock from buy to hold last May just
before Nike warned that profits would fall short of expectations. As more
negative news followed, Some analysts complained that management was hard to
reach for information. One executive, CFO Robert Falcone, antagonized major
shareholders and left in January. Will Nike get back up to
speed Probably it’s one of the world’s most powerful brands, and Knight is
resilient as well as smart. But the recovery will be long and painful. Knight
and his senior managers are currently working on a plan to close facilities and
reduce Nike’s work force worldwide. A big restructuring charge will hit profits
hard this year, and growth will likely be slow during the few years.
In order to recover, Nike will certainly need flesh products to excite
bored consumers. "The lineup for the coming year looks OKEY," says Ralph Parks,
president of Foot Action, the second—largest athletic—shoe specialty retailer.
"It looks better than 1997’s, but I’m not sure that core consumer is quite ready
to jump back in." Most important, Nike needs a new vision of
itself and its brand. This task belongs to Knight, who turned 60 a few weeks ago
and says he plans to work until he dies. That’s a good thing, because the boss’s
favorite motto "There is no finish line" seems more appropriate now than
ever. In America, Nike’s core consumers are ______.
A. the best footballers
B. the most popular basket ball stars
C. the 12-to-24-year old youngsters
D. the cool-conscious adults